The Ultimate Toilet Buying Guide: How to Pick the Right Throne for Your Home

When you're working on a new home construction or remodeling a well-loved bathroom, choosing the best toilet is more important than you might think. Today’s models go beyond basic flush-and-go – they’re engineered for efficiency, comfort, and a little style.

If you're helping homeowners make a selection or just want to stay ahead of the plumbing curve, here’s your go-to toilet buying guide for choosing the perfect porcelain throne.

One-Piece vs. Two-Piece Toilets

Let’s start with the basics. Toilets typically come in two designs:

One-piece toilets have a sleek, modern look with the tank and bowl molded into a single unit. They’re easier to clean and install, but often cost a bit more.

Two-piece toilets are the most common option. The bowls and tanks are separate components, making them easier to move and often more affordable.

Pro Tip: One-piece models are great for modern bathrooms and clients who want low-maintenance cleaning. Two-piece models give you flexibility and are ideal for most standard installs.

Bowl Shape: Round vs. Elongated

Yes, shape matters, especially when it comes to comfort and space. A round bowl is more compact and works well in tight spaces. An elongated bowl offers more surface area and a more comfortable seating experience (especially for adults).

Height: Standard vs. Comfort

Comfort height toilets (sometimes called “chair height”) are about two inches taller than standard models. They’re designed to make sitting and standing easier, especially for older adults or anyone with mobility issues. Standard height measures about 15 inches from floor to seat, while comfort height is around 17-19 inches.

Pro tip: Contractors working on aging-in-place remodels or ADA-compliant projects will want to go with comfort height every time.

Tank Size & Style

When selecting the best toilet tank for your remodeling or building project, several key factors should be considered for functionality, efficiency, and customer satisfaction. 

For best flushing performance, consider the size of flush valves. Larger valves will reduce the likelihood of clogs. To optimize waste removal, look for 2-inch glazed trapways. Finally, be sure that any toilet you choose has good drain-line carry, especially in a bathroom remodel in an older building where plumbing conditions may not be ideal. 

Tanks made of high-quality materials like vitreous china or porcelain are durable and resistant to wear over time. For small bathrooms, a compact or wall-mounted tank can save space; for larger spaces, a one-piece design may offer a more stylish look. For more insight, visit this blog: Exploring The Top 5 Considerations When Selecting A High Tank Toilet.

Seat Selection: Yes, It Matters

Toilet seats are the unsung heroes of bathroom comfort. Choose from standard plastic or wooden seats and slow or quiet-close lids (no more midnight slams!).

Reminder: Many toilets don’t come with a seat included. Make sure to confirm when ordering.

Rough-In Measurements

Before placing any orders, double-check the rough-in distance — the measurement from the wall to the center of the floor drain. The standard is 12 inches, but you’ll also find 10-inch and 14-inch models.

Finishes & Style

Toilets come in a range of finishes, from classic white to matte black and even bone and biscuit. While white is the industry go-to, more clients are asking for finishes that match their bathroom style.

For more thoughts on style, read our blog: Elevate Your Bathroom Renovation: 5 Must-Have Fixtures for a Modern Oasis

Pro tip: Matching the toilet with sinks, tubs, and other fixtures will keep the design cohesive.

To investigate further, we recommend this blog: How to Select a Toilet: A Comprehensive Guide.

Final Flush: What to Remember

At SquarePeg, we carry top-rated toilets and plumbing supplies to help you complete your project with confidence.

Need help finding the right model or accessories? We’re here to help! Reach out to our team or browse online for the latest deals and products.